I asked TiVo to record a program for me this evening. A documentary on the History Channel about, I thought, Japanese POW camps in WWII. This is a topic that interests me, as my grandfather was held for several years in Changi and narrowly missed the Bataan Death March. I've heard him tell many stories over the years, but as that side of my my family is wont to do, we take pretty much every traumatic event in our lives and mock it. I was interested to see a more factual side to what he went through.
Unfortunately, I was unaware that this was part of the History Channel's Reign of Terror week. To me, it looks more like a "Rain of Propaganda".
My suspicions were automatically raised when the host announced that he was coming to us from Saddam Hussein's palace. I'd say that he was only on the screen for maybe 5 of the program's 60 minutes, however he made sure to link the words "Saddam", "Hussein", "evil" and, of course, the perennial favourite "Hitler" at least 10 times. I noted that in both the opening and the closing of the program, the host felt the need to state with utmost confidence that taking down Hussein was something that we "had" to do. Then there's the logo for this extravaganza:

Hussein's eyes, Bin Laden's beard, Stalin's hat, Hitler's moustache ... Why bother pretending to be subtle? Just stick a pair of devil horns a picture of Hussein and be done with it.
That wasn't the worse of it, though. As I was watching the documentary (which was moderately interesting, if not exactly about what I was expecting), I began to notice something. The commentary, despite being about World War II prisoners-of-war, seemed to have a bias. That bias being towards -- you guessed it -- Americans. It was Americans who were beaten, it was Americans who were tortured, it was Americans who were starved. As an afterthought, the program saw fit to occasionally mention that the British, Australian and Canadian soldiers also had a rather unpleasant time. But lo, THE AMERICANS!!!
I fast-forwarded through the last 10 minutes or so, only coming back to listen to the host's closing statements, where he further scratched away at the thin, greasy veneer covering the television event and revealed it for what it truly was: a shallow attempt to rationalize the actions of today with the events of yesterday. It sort of capped the whole thing for me, though, and I began to feel quite disgusted. Here I am, watching the History Channel -- the History Channel -- and I'm feeling bombarded with so much "hail the conquering heroes, God Bless America" sentiment that I thought I was watching the "news" again.
Two things about this piss me off. (I tell a lie, many things about this piss me off, but two are specific to the History Channel's crime here.) Firstly, I'm appalled that they thought it was okay to exploit the true horror that these soldiers went through to further justify this country's egomaniacal ends. That it was done with such a narrow view (they weren't really Allies, they were Americans and Everybody Else) adds to my disgust, but that's the fault of the film makers and not necessarily the History Channel.
Secondly, and perhaps most importantly, when I turn on the History Channel I expect a certain something. It's along the same lines of what I expect to see when I turn on, say, Comedy Central, Animal Planet or Cartoon Network. That is to say that I expect to see that which the channel has chosen as its focus. I don't consider an hour's worth of current pro-American propaganda loosely wrapped in a fifty-year old war to be history. Even those of you who believe with all your heart that war was just and necessary must surely agree that its true repercussions will not be felt and cannot be predicted for several, if not dozens of years. As a result, the current events in Iraq are just that -- current events. They have no place being linked to, let alone compared to, true history. "See how evil German and Japan were back then? By making this loose connection between all easily identifiable badness then and the hazy, obscured, questionable stuff now, we're training you in an almost Pavlovian way to believe that America was right. America is good. America is goooood. Now when we ring this bell, let's see you drool."
Frankly, the realization that even history isn't safe from this disease of blind patriotism disturbs the hell out of me. As the old saying goes, "Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it." If we're casting shadows on the past, we cannot see it clearly, and we're destined to not learn a damned thing.
Listening To:Thunder. Yup, a thunder storm here. Very rare.
Looking Forward To:X-Men: Evolution. At least I know I'll get what I'm expecting when I watch that.




